College baseball is back, and it wasted absolutely no time reminding everyone why the sport is so unpredictable. Week 1 of the 2026 season delivered everything fans could ask for: ranked programs getting knocked off at home, unranked underdogs playing with nothing to lose, and the kind of chaos that only the college game can produce. Tuesday’s midweek slate, featuring 18 teams from D1Baseball’s top 25, became an instant classic — and a sobering wake-up call for several programs with championship aspirations.
Here’s a full breakdown of the biggest storylines from the opening week’s midweek action.
Charleston Ends Coastal Carolina’s 18-Game Home Win Streak
If there’s one result from Week 1 that will define just how wide open this season is, it’s this one. No. 6 Coastal Carolina entered the 2026 season as one of the most dominant home teams in the country. Springs Brooks Stadium had become an absolute fortress — the Chanticleers went 27-3 at home in 2025, losing just three times in 30 contests. Their home win streak stretched all the way back to last April.
College of Charleston didn’t care.
The Cougars came into Conway and handed Coastal Carolina a stunning 4-3 defeat, snapping that 18-game streak in front of what had to be a stunned home crowd. The game was won in the eighth inning, when Charleston strung together a two-run rally to take the lead. Right-hander Dillon Horn walked third baseman Ethan Plyler and surrendered back-to-back singles to catcher Dylan Johnson and first baseman Braeden Smith, loading the bases with nobody out. When lefty Colby Richardson came in to relieve, the Cougars capitalized — left fielder Payton Frehner’s groundout scored one run, and designated hitter Jackson Berini’s sacrifice fly put Charleston ahead.
From there, right-hander Kurt Rogers was absolutely dominant. He retired eight consecutive batters to close out the game, with first baseman Braeden Smith making a crucial play on the final out. It was a complete team effort from a Charleston squad that served notice that this season will not be business as usual for the nation’s elite programs.
Coastal Carolina will look to regroup this weekend, hosting the Baseball at the Beach tournament against Illinois and VCU.
Morehead State Stuns No. 18 Kentucky in Lexington
If you blinked, you might have missed Morehead State’s significance in the college baseball landscape — but the Eagles made sure Tuesday’s result would not be forgotten anytime soon. The program hadn’t beaten a ranked opponent since 2021, and hadn’t taken down Kentucky specifically since 2014. Both of those droughts ended Tuesday night, as Morehead State walked out of Lexington with an 8-6 victory over the No. 18 Wildcats.
The game was a back-and-forth battle through the middle innings. Third baseman Aubrey Kearns was the Eagles’ standout performer, delivering an RBI single in the first inning and then a two-run blast in the third to give Morehead State an early cushion. Kentucky fought back through catcher Owen Jenkins, whose two-RBI single in the fifth gave the Wildcats a 6-5 lead and looked like it might flip the momentum entirely.
It didn’t. Morehead State answered in the sixth with two runs to retake the lead 7-6, then added an insurance run in the ninth for good measure. Kentucky’s offense simply went cold after Jenkins’ big hit, striking out five times down the stretch and failing to advance a runner past first base. The Wildcats now head to Evansville for a three-game weekend series with some serious questions about their lineup’s consistency.
For Morehead State, this is a program-defining win. A victory over a ranked SEC program on the road proves the Eagles belong on anyone’s watch list for bracket-busting potential this season.
Cincinnati Shuts Out No. 9 Auburn in a Dominant Road Statement
The most complete performance of the midweek slate belonged to the Cincinnati Bearcats, who traveled to Auburn and produced a jaw-dropping 8-0 shutout of the No. 9 Tigers. It marked Auburn’s first home loss to an unranked opponent since April 1 of last season, when UAB handed them a 4-2 defeat — and the Bearcats made it look almost easy.
Cincinnati took command immediately, plating runs in each of the first two innings to build a 2-0 lead they would protect all night. Credit belongs to the Bearcats’ pitching staff, which was brilliant from first pitch to last. Dillon Schueler set an aggressive tone with four strikeouts across the first two innings, and Carson Marsh earned his second win of the season with a strong showing in the middle innings. Joel Piñeiro came on in the ninth and slammed the door, completing one of the most impressive road pitching efforts of the young season.
Auburn starter Andreas Alvarez was actually solid — he struck out eight over four innings and allowed just one earned run — but the Tigers’ offense gave him nothing to work with. Designated hitter Enzo Infelise led Cincinnati’s attack, going 3-for-5 with an RBI single in the eighth. Christian Mitchell then delivered the knockout blow in the ninth, ripping a two-RBI double off the wall to push the final margin to eight.
The Bearcats next travel to Birmingham to face UAB on Thursday. Auburn, meanwhile, will need to take a hard look at an offense that produced nothing against an unranked opponent at home.
UT Arlington Runs Away from No. 7 TCU in Explosive Upset
The most lopsided upset of the night belonged to UT Arlington, who jumped on No. 7 TCU early and never looked back in an 11-8 victory. The Mavericks came out of the gates swinging, posting four runs in the first inning and forcing TCU starter Nolan Johnson off the mound after just a third of an inning. When reliever Tyler Phenow entered, he couldn’t stop the bleeding either — UTA led 9-0 after just two innings.
To TCU’s credit, the Horned Frogs didn’t quit. Outfielder Chase Brunson gave the home crowd something to cheer about in the fourth with a two-run RBI double, and the team ultimately scored eight runs on the night, showing there’s still plenty of offensive firepower in Fort Worth. But climbing out of a 9-0 hole against a Mavericks squad playing with supreme confidence proved to be too steep a climb. A two-run sixth inning by UTA effectively sealed the win.
It was a bruising loss for TCU, but the Horned Frogs have an immediate opportunity to answer — they face No. 1 UCLA in Los Angeles this weekend. That’s about as high a stage as it gets, and how TCU responds will say a lot about the character of this team.
What Week 1 Tells Us About the 2026 Season
The takeaways from opening week are already piling up, and they paint an exciting picture for the months ahead.
Upsets are coming early and often. With 18 top-25 teams in action on Tuesday alone, four of them went home with losses. That’s not a fluke — it reflects the depth and competitiveness of the college baseball landscape in 2026. Any team that sleeps on a midweek opponent is going to pay for it.
Home field advantage is not guaranteed. Both Coastal Carolina and Auburn lost at home to unranked opponents. The mystique of a home crowd and familiar surroundings can only do so much against a well-prepared team playing loose and fearless baseball.
Mid-major programs are ready to compete. Charleston, Morehead State, and Cincinnati (though the Bearcats are no stranger to big wins) all punched well above their weight class. These programs are recruiting better, coaching better, and refusing to be intimidated by the sport’s elite brands.
Pitching wins in college baseball. Cincinnati’s staff produced a shutout. Charleston’s Kurt Rogers retired eight straight to close a game. Morehead State’s pitchers held Kentucky scoreless over the final three innings. In a college game with aluminum bats and high scoring potential, dominant pitching separates good teams from great ones.
The 2026 college baseball season is only a week old, and it has already delivered more drama than most seasons see in a month. Buckle up — if Week 1 is any indication, we’re in for an unforgettable ride to Omaha.
Stay up to date with all college baseball coverage at baseballresource.org.
